The UK regulator now has its first fake review cases under the new law. The safest way to get great reviews is also the simplest. Ask everyone, ask for the story, and reply as yourself.
Reviews are often the first thing a buyer reads about you, and the last thing they check before they call. So knowing how to ask customers for reviews in a fair way is now part of running a good business, not a nice extra. The rules have tightened, and the tools buyers use read your reviews more closely than ever.
By the end of this post you will know what the regulator is looking at, what Google's own rules say, and a simple routine that brings in reviews worth reading.
What is the CMA doing about fake reviews?
Quick Answer: Since April 2025, fake reviews and hidden incentives for reviews are banned outright in the UK, and in March 2026 the CMA opened its first five investigations under the new law.
On 27 March 2026 the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) opened five investigations into review practices. They look at things like whether staff were asked to write positive reviews, whether customers got discounts for five-star reviews without that being disclosed, and whether negative reviews were kept out of star ratings. The CMA has not reached any conclusions, and no business should be assumed to have broken the law.
These practices have been on the banned list since April 2025, under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act. The CMA's chief executive, Sarah Cardell, said: "Fake reviews strike at the heart of consumer trust".
In its update of 14 October 2026, the CMA said these cases are still open. It also made a point every owner should hear: commissioning reviews is not just about paying people. Asking staff to write reviews could be unlawful too.
→ If a review would not exist without a nudge, a favour or a discount, it does not belong on your profile.
Is it fine to ask only my happy customers?
Quick Answer: No. Google's own rules ban selectively asking for positive reviews, so ask every customer in the same way.
Many owners send review requests only to the customers they know loved the work. It feels sensible. Google does not allow it.
Google's policy for reviews on Maps lists "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers" as rating manipulation. It also bans offering incentives, such as payment, discounts or free services, in exchange for any review. And it flags conflicts of interest, such as current or former staff reviewing the business.
The fair way is also the easy way: ask everyone. Same message, same timing, every customer. If someone had a bad experience, you want to know. A calm, helpful reply to a fair complaint can show more about you than ten five-star reviews.
How do I get reviews that tell a story, not just stars?
Quick Answer: Ask one simple question about what the customer was worried about at the start and how it turned out.
A five-star review that says "Great service" is nice. Now imagine a review that says "We were worried the kitchen would take months. It was done in three weeks and they cleaned up every day" is far more useful. It answers a real buyer's fear in a real customer's words.
You cannot write the review for them, and you should never tell them what to say. But you can make it easier to share the story. Try a request like this:
- Thank them by name. Keep it personal and short.
- Ask one open question. "What were you unsure about before we started, and how did it go?"
- Give them the direct link. Google suggests sharing a review link or a QR code.
- Ask once, then leave it. One reminder at most.
Reviews like these feed signal 4 in our 19 trust signals, review score and volume. With permission, they can also become the raw material for signal 11, case studies and testimonials.
Liyana's Insight: "It has to be word by word, and you need a release signed by the client to put it onto Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, all of those platforms."
That is the rule we work to. If you reuse a review anywhere, use the customer's exact words, and get their permission first.
Why should I reply to reviews with my own name?
Quick Answer: A reply signed by a real person shows there is someone accountable behind the business, and it gives future buyers a feel for how you treat people.
Google's help page on reviews says replies should be professional, polite, short and simple, and that you should apologise when it is right to. We add one more habit: sign it.
A made-up example: "Thanks, Sarah, it was a pleasure. James, Director" reads very differently from "Thank you for your feedback." A name says a real person read this and cares. It is the same idea as named authors on your service pages. Buyers trust people, not logos.
For a tricky review, keep it calm. Thank them, say sorry for how they felt, offer to talk offline, and sign your name. Never argue in public.
Would a buyer reading your replies today know who runs your business?
What review routine can I start this week?
Quick Answer: Set one moment after every finished job when every customer gets the same short request, and block ten minutes a week to reply to every review with your name.
- Pick the moment. The day the job is signed off works for most services.
- Write one message. Thank them, ask the one open question, add the link.
- Send it to everyone. No filtering.
- Reply weekly. Every review, good or bad, signed by a person.
- Write a short review policy. The CMA's guidance for businesses that publish reviews says you should have a published policy that clearly bans fake reviews.
Want to keep the flow steady? Read why review velocity beats review count , or see how we set up AI review automation that still asks everyone the same way.
Get the free 19 trust signals briefing to see where reviews sit among the rest.
FAQ
Can I offer a prize draw for leaving a review?
Google's policy bans offering incentives such as payment, discounts or free goods or services in exchange for a review. UK law also bans reviews that hide the fact they were incentivised. The safe choice is no incentives at all.
Can my staff leave reviews for the business?
No. Google lists current or former employment as a conflict of interest, and the CMA has said asking staff to write reviews could be unlawful.
Should I reply to every review?
Yes, if you can. Google's own tips say to keep replies professional, polite and short. A short, signed reply to every review shows buyers a real person is listening.
What if I get an unfair negative review?
Reply calmly and briefly, offer to talk offline, and sign your name. If the review breaks Google's content policy, you can report it through your Business Profile.
Sources
- Fake and misleading reviews: 5 businesses under CMA investigation, GOV.UK, 27 March 2026 (checked 27 October 2026)
- Direct consumer enforcement: 18 months on, CMA blog, 14 October 2026 (checked 27 October 2026)
- Short guide for businesses publishing consumer reviews (CMA208), GOV.UK, 4 April 2025 (checked 27 October 2026)
- Maps user contributed content policy: prohibited and restricted content, Google (checked 27 October 2026)
- Tips to get more reviews, Google Business Profile Help (checked 27 October 2026)
Hi, I'm Liyana and I wrote this article.
If this article made your head spin a little, good. That means you are paying attention. Search has genuinely changed and there is a lot to get across. What I love about this work is breaking it down for businesses who are brilliant at what they do but have not got time to become SEO nerds. That is my job. You just focus on what you are good at and let me handle the rest.
More articles on my page, plus an easy way to get in touch. Come and find me. Find me here →
Keep reading
Review Velocity Beats Review Count (and How to Pick the Right Channel)
A hundred reviews from 2022 cannot tell a buyer whether you are still good today, and a TikTok account cannot help a business whose buyers never search there.
Read more →
What questions should a service page answer?
Google ran two core updates in the first half of 2026 and gave site owners the same advice both times. There is no quick fix. There is a better page.
Read more →
Can a small business get recommended by ChatGPT? Neil Patel says yes, and I mostly agree
Neil Patel's team says small brands can beat big ones in AI search. Here's what our client data shows, and the one part I'd skip.
Read more →